← All workServices · Performance-based contracting

Renegotiating a contract so both sides got what they needed

The contract was being met, and the customer was still unhappy. New metrics built around what the customer actually needed, and what the business could actually control, fixed both sides of the deal.

Work I did as an analyst at Lockheed Martin, described without program or customer names.

This is follow-on work to the first negotiation.

The situation

Leadership asked me to support the renegotiation of the business’s performance-based agreement with its main customer, who was a primary growth driver for the business.

The customer was unhappy, despite our successful delivery on the previous agreement. The business met the obligations of the previous performance-based agreement, but both parties captured a lesson learned in the initial period of performance: a disconnect existed between the outcome delivered and the outcome the end customer wanted. The end customer was frustrated because they were obligated to pay, but they did not get what they really wanted.

What was at stake

The business forecasted 30% year-over-year growth of its service business for the next 5 years.

What I did

My task included 1) continued assessment of the business’s ability to meet the performance levels demanded in this new agreement, 2) recommendations of “better” metrics that were likely to satisfy both the business and the customer, and 3) real-time negotiation support.

Problem discovery sessions, end-customer feedback sessions, and stakeholder interviews gave me a robust understanding of why the agreement needed to evolve. I then conducted a deep quantitative analysis of our ability to perform on the original metrics and new metrics. This step included analysis of historical performance, statistical and simulation modeling of the service process, and a model that translated performance metric outcomes into financial terms, including incentives and margin. I then identified a set of industry-standard performance metrics that aligned to end-customer requirements and to what we could reliably deliver.

From there, I helped leadership understand the story the data was telling. Leadership again asked me to tell the same story to the customer at the negotiation.

What changed

The negotiation was collaborative, and it ended with a satisfied end customer and a contract that met the business’s financial goals.

  1. Expectations grounded in data. During negotiation preparation, I helped leadership understand the value of each new metric, both to the business and to the end customer.
  2. Data-driven negotiation. During the negotiation and with my real-time support, the business negotiated service levels that were achievable and fully within its control.
  3. Financial success. During contract execution, the business achieved the desired financial outcomes of the contract.

Let’s run the numbers before you commit.

A few sentences is plenty: what you’re weighing, when you need to decide, and what it costs if you get it wrong. I read and reply to every message myself.