← All workServices · Performance-based contracting

Walking back service levels the business couldn't control, before signing

A fast-growing service business was about to commit to performance metrics it couldn't fully control. Modeling its real capability reset expectations before the negotiation, not after the penalties.

Work I did as an analyst at Lockheed Martin, described without program or customer names.

The situation

Leadership asked me to support the negotiation of a new, performance-based agreement with the business’s main customer, who was a primary growth driver for the business. The primary problems I encountered were two-fold:

  1. Lack of direct control of the outcome. The new metrics the customer required were largely out of the business’s direct control. We could influence the metrics, but customer behavior ultimately drove the outcome.
  2. False confidence. The business had been successful in winning and executing on previous “time and materials”-based service agreements, and this was a new, performance-based agreement. Prior success fueled optimism that we could meet any service level the customer was willing to pay for.

What was at stake

The business forecasted 30% year-over-year growth of its service business for the next 5 years.

What I did

My task included 1) an assessment of the business’s ability to meet the performance levels demanded in this new agreement, 2) recommendations on the service levels we should be willing to commit to, and 3) real-time negotiation support.

Problem discovery sessions and stakeholder interviews gave me a robust understanding of the problem. I then conducted a deep quantitative analysis of our ability to perform. This step included analysis of historical performance, statistical and simulation modeling of the service process, and a model that translated performance metric outcomes into financial terms, including incentives and margin.

From there, I helped leadership understand the story the data was telling. Leadership then asked me to tell the same story to the customer at the negotiation.

What changed

The analysis proved critical to the business’s financial performance on the new agreement.

  1. Expectations grounded in data. During negotiation preparation, the team reset its own expectations (reduced its optimism) about its ability to deliver to the customer’s demands.
  2. Data-driven negotiation. During the negotiation and with my real-time support, the business successfully negotiated lower service levels in the agreement.
  3. Financial success. During contract execution, the business achieved the desired financial outcomes of the contract.

This work led to follow-on work redefining the metrics themselves.

Let’s run the numbers before you commit.

A few sentences is plenty: what you’re weighing, when you need to decide, and what it costs if you get it wrong. I read and reply to every message myself.